Gault&Millau — 15
The modern Brasserie Monti in the luxury hotel The Alpina is Gstaad's surprise hit of the season. Eighteen-point chef Martin Göschel steps back, preferring not to pamper and confuse his clientele in the new restaurant with bold combinations; instead, he cooks dishes that everyone knows and loves. This perfectly captures the spirit of the times.
Guests are welcome to share starters if they wish: a massive "Big Burrata" arrives at the table, along with carne cruda (made from veal fillet) and vitello tonnato. A few dishes are outstanding, such as the classic shrimp cocktail. For this, Martin Göschel relies on noble, freshly cooked Black Tiger prawns, prepares the cocktail sauce fresh each time, and gives it a kick with a touch of chili; the classic starter is served in an elegant cocktail glass at room temperature, which suits the prawns perfectly. The foie gras is also excellent: the chef and his 35 (!) cooks (with the talented Martina Siegrist on the demanding saucier station) poach it at a low temperature. Its creaminess is captivating, and the use of port wine and Madeira makes itself quite noticeably felt.
A cornerstone of the "Monti" concept: the "Meat Trolley"! An elegant meat cart is presented with justified pride: well-aged rib eye, beef fillet, double veal chop, tenderloin, and chateaubriand, primarily sourced from the cult-favorite "Buure Metzg" butcher shop in the village! The server dons white gloves, picks up a sharp knife and a digital scale, and slices exactly what the guest desires. The kitchen ensures the perfect level of doneness and the requested sauce: veal jus, béarnaise, albufera. Special requests for larger parties are fulfilled without complaint when ordered in advance. During our visit, two enormous filets mignon Wellington were sliced tableside, revealing their Instagram-worthy pastry patterns, and two plump, juicy geese (with crispy skin) were carved. As a father himself, Martin Göschel knows from personal experience what children enjoy. That is why the orecchia di elefante—a breaded giant veal schnitzel modeled after the Milanese version—also makes it onto the "Monti" menu.
The fish offerings do not fall short either. The snow-white Saint Pierre with black truffle and very Italian-style risotto is excellent, and the bouillabaisse comes in a premium version that only a luxury hotel can afford. There are no intimidating rockfish swimming in the soup; instead, it features half a lobster, half a langoustine, scallops, turbot, sea bass, and sole. Naturally, the chef adds an extra kick here as well: saffron threads provide a powerful depth in the deep bowl. Rouille sauce and garlic bread are served alongside. A bit too much garlic all at once.